Hendricks County, Indiana, is home to numerous amazing local pizza spots serving up unique and delicious pies.
These restaurants are known for great flavor, strong local followings and welcoming atmospheres. Some specialize in truly authentic pizza, while others have become favorites for their unique crusts or specialty ingredients.
No matter your style, there’s a pizza place here that’s worth the trip. Here are seven standouts to try.
1. Two Guys Pies, Danville
Located next to The Beehive, just east of the courthouse square, Two Guys Pies is a cozy, family-run pizzeria serving large 18-inch square pies, wings, pizza rollers, wraps, and a salad bar on its vast menu.
They offer gluten-free and cauliflower crust options, with standout choices like their beer‑cheese pizza and BBQ pie. Known for a friendly atmosphere and half‑off wine on Thirsty Thursdays, Two Guys Pies is a great spot for family and group dinners.
2. CJ's Pizza, Clayton
CJ’s Pizza in Clayton is a local favorite that brings big flavor to a small-town setting. Their hand-tossed pizzas come loaded with toppings, and the tap room offers a wide selection of craft beers on draft.
Guests love the menu options and ambiance of this shop with indoor and outdoor seating and occasional live music.
3. Amo Pizza Shop
This charming take-out pizzeria inside Amo’s General Store is known for its bold specialty pies, such as the “Around the World,” which features more than a dozen toppings. They also have popular cheeseburger and buffalo chicken "Angry Bird" pizzas.
This shop has become a local favorite, so grab a pizza and don't forget their deli‑style subs, breadsticks and salads.
4. Rock Star Pizza, Brownsburg
Owned by community-focused husband-and-wife duo Ron and Colby Mathews, Rock Star Pizza features unique creations like the “Mac Daddy” (Big Mac–style) and Caribbean Twist, which has a honey‑mustard base.
Their lunch buffet is a hit during the week, and their house‑made keto crust and desserts draw fans from around the Midwest.
5. Perillo's Pizzeria, North Salem
This beloved, family-owned North Salem pizza shop is celebrated for scratch-made Italian dishes and authentic Sicilian-style pizza or New York-style by the slice.
Perillo’s loyal locals rave about their garlic rolls and classic pies, but you'll need to pay with cash if you decide to visit. They don't accept cards.
6. Pizzaville, Avon
A favorite since 2013, Pizzaville on Rockville Road is known for consistently good slices and speedy service.
Owner and Chef Jeet Lalli has more than 25 years of experience as a master pizza maker. He offers a menu with all the classics, including a fun Hawaiian pizza.
7. So Italian! Brownsburg
So Italian! in Brownsburg and its sister restaurant Nonna’s in Plainfield serve family recipes passed down over generations.
Their menus include pizza, pasta, calzones, keto and gluten-free items. When you're finished, try a classic Italian dessert, like cannoli or tiramisu, or try their Nutella pizza for something fun and sweet.
