After setting up shop in May 2019, Sweet Paige's quickly became a favorite spot in Brownsburg to satisfy one's sweet tooth. Many loyal customers were saddened when the shop closed for business at the end of 2022.

Well, it's time to dry those tears and rejoice because Sweet Paige's is back...and sweeter than ever!  

Paige Barnhart

Paige Barnhart, owner of Sweet Paige's in Brownsburg

As the owner and head baker, Paige Barnhart is a self-taught master at whipping up a variety of delicious baked goods. Her initial foray into selling her treats included taking over her mom's kitchen.

She soon opened her first shop in a renovated home on Main Street in Brownsburg. Much to her customers' dismay, she closed up shop after three years and moved out of state.

New Storefront

Counter of Treats at Sweet Paige's in Brownsburg

Paige recently returned to Brownsburg and so did her shop in a new storefront. She learned a lot during her first venture and now has a location on Main Street that is better suited to her needs, including plenty of storage and counter space.

To meet the demand for her delectable goodies, she elicited help from her mom (also an extraordinary baker) who is now donning an apron at Sweet Paige's.

Same Tasty Treats

Cupcakes from Sweet Paige's in Brownsburg

While the address has changed, Sweet Paige's still serves up decadent cupcakes, cookies, cakes and more as former customers flock in and new ones discover the shop every week.

Paige determines the daily flavors for cakes and macarons and weekly cupcake flavors based on her own inclination as well as customer recommendations. Cnnamon rolls, scones and muffins also make appearances in the display case.

Beautiful Lizton Lodge (Via Jennifer Krampitz Photography).

Free Wedding Guide!

Get your insider guide to all things Weddings in Hendricks County with our FREE Wedding Guide. Download or order a print copy today!


Lemon/Lime Macarons from Sweet Paige's in Brownsburg

Macarons are their number one sellers, with people traveling quite a distance to get these colorful French cookie sandwiches (not to be confused with the coconut-based macaroon).

Paige adds her own unique style with oversized macarons in fun flavors such as Fruity Pebbles, creme brulee and puppy chow. Check Facebook for daily flavor options.

Special Order

Cakes from Sweet Paige's in Brownsburg

Special ordering of cakes, macarons and cupcakes is available (including gluten-free options), typically within 72 hours, and can be ordered through the website

Catering and artistically designed tiered wedding cakes are also possible. Call to schedule a consultation three to four months in advance.

Shop Details

Cookies from Sweet Paige's in Brownsburg

  • Location
  • Phone: (317) 966-5707
  • Website
  • Check Facebook for daily flavors and notification of sold-out items
  • Hours: Wednesday-Friday, 10 a.m.-6 p.m.; Saturday 10 a.m.-3 p.m.; Closed Sunday, Monday and Tuesday