Where to Order Holiday Appetizers & Desserts
Published on
I love the sweets and treats offered in Hendricks County, and most of the time, it’s a quick stop to grab fresh bread, cookies or ice cream.
But over the holidays, it’s often the last thing I think of, and by the time I consider bringing a charcuterie board or yummy pie from my favorite place to the family get-together, it’s too late.
When the calendar starts filling up and Christmas shopping is upon us, it’s easy to forget that our local stores, bakeries and restaurants also experience a surge in orders. That’s why it’s always good to think through what you’ll need this season and order early!
Here’s a list of spots in Hendricks County:
Mandy's Ice Cream
It’s never a bad time for ice cream, and with Mandy’s in Brownsburg, you can surprise your host or guests with an ice cream pie or cake this season.
Order by Nov. 23 for pickup before Thanksgiving, and don’t forget to grab a pint or quart of your favorite flavor while you’re at it.
Mokey's on the Square
Mokey’s in Danville is a great spot to enjoy a Ladies Night Out, grab a cocktail or glass of wine after work. You can also sign up for one of their many community events.
As for the holidays, order early to pick up Thanksgiving-themed small, medium and large boards packed with meats, cheeses, fruits, veggies and more.
Beasley's Orchard
Did you know Beasley’s Orchard offers Thanksgiving pies in addition to the fresh produce found at the market? Options include Dutch Apple, Cherry Crumble, Pecan, Pumpkin, Sugar Cream and a take-and-bake, Strawberry Rhubarb.
A limited number of pies are available for pickup, so place your order prior to Nov. 21 for Thanksgiving and as soon as possible for the Christmas season.
Sweet Paige's
Impress friends and family with a unique sweet treat this holiday season. In addition to their regular menu, Sweet Paige’s is offering a Pie Flight (four 5-inch pies: Sugar Cream, Pumpkin, Pecan and Chocolate Peanut Butter) and a Thanksgiving Treat Box, including a variety of cookies, brownies, candied almonds and snickerdoodle puppy chow.
Orders must be placed by Nov. 20 for Nov. 25 pickup!
Bread Basket Cafe & Bakery
At the family-owned Bread Basket Café and Bakery in Danville, save time prepping for the family dinner by grabbing Thanksgiving bread and rolls with flavors ranging from Honey Oat to Cranberry Orange.
They also sell an assortment of made-from-scratch pies and delicious holiday cakes. Pre-orders are open through Nov. 22.
Knead the Dough
Knead the Dough in Lizton suggests letting them make the mess in their kitchen for your holiday gathering. Pick up a variety of pies, turkey and leaf-shaped cookies, muffins, loaves of bread, cinnamon rolls and more.
They’ll even cater your holiday party with trays of meats and cheeses, veggies and dessert. Just order soon before time runs out.
Mayberry Cafe
Known for their comfort food that reminds me of my grandma’s, the Mayberry Café in Danville has you covered for the holidays too.
Order their signature butterscotch pie and/or raspberry vanilla cake for your holiday gathering. Preorders close on Nov. 22!
Momma Shell's Cookies
It’s true, you can stop by during the week and pick up a dozen of your favorite cookies. But if you’re looking for something a little extra special, try Momma Shell’s fall flavors, Apple Blossom and Pumpkin Peak in a Thanksgiving-themed platter.
Want another unique idea? Order a Fall Family Kit, and decorate your own Thanksgiving sugar cookies, while creating memories together.
Sweet Minis Cake Bar
An assortment of mini cakes from Sweet Minis Cake Bar in Plainfield would be a big hit, with flavors ranging from Cookie Monster to Confetti.
But did you also know you can pre-order a 6-inch carrot cake, 9-inch cheesecake or delicious family-sized banana pudding (with or without fresh banana slices)? The last day to pre-order is Nov. 17!
The Singing Crust Bakery
Just in time for the Thanksgiving holiday, The Singing Crust in Clayton has added coconut cream and chocolate cream pies to its menu. They also have classic apple, cherry and pumpkin, to name a few.
If you want to go beyond desserts, check out the assortment of breads, rolls, stuffing and breakfast pastries, including blueberry scones and almond croissants.
Brie & Bartlett
They’re undergoing changes right now, closing their dine-in restaurant and adding a local food truck, The Grazy Train, as they focus on catering and events.
But this holiday season, look for special holiday-themed charcuterie and pop-up pick-up locations on The Grazy Train Facebook page. Owner Presley Pullen said their storefront will also remain open for charcuterie pickups only, but holiday orders must be received by Nov. 24.



















